Case type: Tithes
Summary: March v Michael Jones: a dispute is raised over whether Michael has been correctly paying tithes for the animals pasturing on his land below Exe Bridge in Exeter.
Source: Devon Heritage Centre, Chanter 866
Gloss: definitions of key terminology.
Interpretation: matters of interest and importance relating to how evidence recorded in the depositions is analysed.
Technicalities of the court: procedural information about the operation of the courts and the recording of depositional evidence.
Quarto Novembris 1634. Sup[er] 3 ar[ticu]lo li[bel]li et sched ex parte Mr Marsh dat.
Testis 1
Joh[n]is Haysome Civi[ta]te Exon ubi mora[m] ferit p[er] 34 annos ant ultra etate sue Lii annoru[m] ant cir[citer] testis p[ro]ductus admiss iuratus &c.
Ad Tertiu[m] ar[ticu]lu[m] Li[bel]li r[esp]ondet et ad sc[he]d[ulu]m et 3 ar[ticu]los
sched deponit et dicit That the ar[ticu]lat Michaell Joanes all the tyme ar[ticu]lat and Longe before hath had and held to pasture The
Shillowes belowe Exe bridge, conteyninge about 4 Acres of Land and hath yerely kepte thereon sometymes horsses and sometymes
Kine Feedinge and depasturinge,
thereon and
some horsses he taketh yn to pasture of other mens, And this deponent saith That in his
Iudgement the Pasture there eaten up by the horsses and
Kine of the said Joanes and such as he taketh yn to pasture was well
worth yeerely the said yeeres six pounds at the Least, and this depon[en]t saith also that he hath seene at some tymes
the said servants or servant of the said Joanes to milke some
kyne in the said Grownde w[hi]ch have there depastured. but
how often or what the milke or
whitsoele is worth he cannott Iudge ut dicit. Reddens rac[i]o[n]em deponis sive for that this deponent
dwelleth very neire the said Grownds and well knoweth that the said Joanes hath had the said Grownde many yeres and, the said
Joanes hath kepte a horse to pasture for this deponent w[whi]ch and for divers others w[hi]ch divers
often tymes pasture in the said Shillowes. And saith also that
the said Shilowes is reputed to be w[i]thin the p[ar]ish of St Mary Steps
ar[ticu]lat all or most parte thereof, and whither all of it be in that p[ar]ish or part in some other
p[ar]ish this deponent doth not Certenly knowe ut dicit. et al[ite]r nescit deponere ut dicit
Sexto novembris Anno d[omin]i 1634
Testis 2.
Joh[n]es Underhill p[ar]o[chi]e S[anc]te Trinitate Exon ubi mora[m] ferit p[er] xiiii annos ant Cir[citer] etate sue Lvi annoru[m] ant cir[citer] testis p[ro]ductus &c
Ad 3 ar[ticu]lu[m] li[be]li ad 2 et 3. ar[ticu]los sched annex deponit et dicit That the ar[ticu]lat Michaell Joanes hath had and
kept to pasture Certen growndes called the Shillowes lyeinge below Ex Bridge all the tyme li[bel]led. and saith That at sometymes he keepeth thereon
some horsses & other beasts of his owne and some of other mens w[hi]ch he tookes yn to pasture, and saith That he iudgeth the pasture of the said
groundes yerely soe eaten up there is worth
xxs and better, And saith
That part of the said Shillowes are accompted and reputed to be Lyinge w[i]thin
the p[ar]ish of St Mary Steps ar[ticu]lat but how much this deponent knoweth not ut dicit. Et p[re]misse deponit ex p[ro]pria sua
scien
this deponent havinge at divers tymes a horse to pasture w[i]th the said Joanes w[hi]ch he hath at sometymes also
knowne to pasture w[i]th this the said Joanes his horsses in the said Shillowes ut dicit. et al[ite]r nescit deponere ut dicit
25. novembris 1634.
Testis 3.
Alicia hingston de Civitate Exon ubi mora[m] fecit p[er] xxvi. annos ant cir[citer] etate sue 40 annorum ant cir[citer] testis p[ro]ducta &c
Ad tertiu[m] ar[ticu]lu[m] li[bel]li et 2. et 3 ar[ticu]los sched
deponit et dicit That this deponent
did lyve with Mr Streete Late of St Edmundes three yeres
and halfe or thereabout ended now about a yere synce. and in that tyme the said Mr Streete
did keepe three mylch
kyne w[hi]ch com[m]only all the som[m]er tyme did pasture upon the groundes
of the ar[ticu]lat Joanes in ev[er]y the said yeres, and saith that
sometymes they did pasture
belowe the bridge in the groundes called the Shillowes and sometymes in the Bonay &
sometymes in other groundes adioyning there called the shootinge marsh w[hi]ch lieth all at
com[m]on w[i]thin what p[ar]ish this deponent knoweth not. and saith That
this deponent hath divers
tymes in the said yeeres mylked the said
kyne in the groundes called the Shillowes, and
saith that the said Joanes did contynually most com[m]onlie all the tyme aforesaid, keepe horsses and
kyne
of his owne and some other he tooke in to pasture upon the foresaid groundes but what the
pasture was yerely worth or the milke she knoweth not ut dicit
4 November 1634. On Article 3 of the libel and schedule on the part of Mr Marsh.
Witness 1
John Haysome of the city of Exeter where he has lived for 34 years, age 52, witness produced, admitted and sworn etc.
To the third article of the libel and schedule responds and to Article 3 of the schedule he deposes and says
that the articulated Michael Jones all the time articulated and long before has had and held to pasture the
Shillows below Exe bridge, containing about four acres of land. And has yearly kept thereon sometimes horses and sometimes
kine feeding and depasturing thereon. And
some horses he takes in to pasture of
other mens. And this deponent says that in his judgement the pasture there eaten up by the horses and
kine of the said Jones'
and such as he takes in to pasture was well worth yearly the said years six pounds at the least. And this deponent says also that he has seen at some times
the said servants or servant of the said Jones to milk some
kine in the said ground which have there depastured. But
how often or what the milk or
whitesole is worth, he cannot judge. The reason he deposes this is for that this deponent
dwells very near the said grounds and well knows that the said Jones has had the said ground many years and the said
Jones has kept a horse to pasture for this deponent which and for divers others which diverse often times pasture in the said
Shillows. And says also that
the said Shillows is reputed to be within the parish of St Mary Steps
articulated all or most part thereof, and whether all of it be in that parish or part in some other
parish this deponent does not certainly know. And otherwise he cannot depose.
Sixth November 1634.
Witness 2
John Underhill of the parish of St Trinity Exeter where he has lived for 14 years, around 56 years old. Witness produced etc.
To Article 3 of the libel and Articles 2 and 3 of the annexed schedule he deposes and says that the articulate Michael Jones has had and
kept to pasture certain grounds called the Shillows lying below Exe Bridge all the time libelled. And says that at sometimes he keeps thereon
some horses and other beasts of his own and some of other men's which he took in to pasture. And says that he judges the pasture of the said
grounds yearly so eaten up there is worth
20s and better. And says
that part of the said Shillows are accounted and reputed to be lying within
the parish of St Mary Steps articulated but how much this deponent knows not. And he deposes this from personal experience,
this deponent having at diverse times
a horse to pasture with the said Jones which he has at sometimes also known to pasture with this the said Jones his horses in the said Shillows.
And otherwise he cannot depose or say.
25 November 1634.
Witness 3
Alice Hingston of the city of Exeter where she has lived for 26 years, around 40 years old. Witness produced etc.
To the third article of the libel and Articles 2 and 3 of the schedule she deposes and says that this deponent
did live with Mr Street, late of St Edmonds,
three years and half or thereabout ended now about a year since. And in that time the said Mr Street did keep three milk
kine which
commonly all the Summer time did pasture upon the grounds of the articulated Jones in every the said years. And says that
sometimes they
did pasture below the bridge in the grounds called the Shillows and sometimes in the Bonhay and sometimes in other grounds adjoining there called the Shooting
Marsh, which lies all at common within, what parish this deponent knows not. And says that
this deponent has diverse times in the said years
milked the said
kine in the grounds called the Shillows. And says that the said Jones did
continually most commonly all the time aforesaid keep horses and
kine of his own and some other he took in to pasture upon the foresaid grounds but what the
pasture was yearly worth or the milk she knows not.
This is a dispute between private parties, known in the church courts as an instance suit.
Other parishioners use Michael Jones’ land to pasture their horses, presumably at a cost.
A kine is a milk cow.
White sole was milk turned into cheese.
Tithes were a form of clerical income paid to the parish vicar. In tithe disputes, it is important to establish which parish the ground lies in, and where animals were grazing or pasturing to establish which parish vicar was entitled to the income.
Witnesses were asked to sign their depositions: signatures range from full names to simply initials or marks (sometimes images linked with trades).
Alice may have been a servant to Mr Street; however, this is not specified in the deposition.
Evidence of women's work activity: milking cows.
's' used after a number refers to shillings (e.g. 20 shillings).